Denied by Fidelity!

Posted by | Posted in Lessons Learned | Posted on 12-01-2008

My company has an ESPP plan which (in case you’re not familiar with this term) is a way for employees to buy company stock at a discount — it stands for Employee Stock Purchase Plan.  It’s a great thing because they purchase it at a 15% discount to it’s average price over the time the money has been collected for this purpose.  They purchase the stock twice a year, so in a way it’s also a forced savings account — also a good thing.  So even if all you do is flip the stock, you’re likely to make at least the 15%.  If the stock has risen significantly, then you make more. If it’s dropped significantly then better to hold it for a while.

Fidelity manages this program for my company.  And, being an educated option trader I thought I would sell covered calls or buy protective puts on this stock for a while. You have to apply for option trading at Fidelity but that’s not the problem since I think that’s pretty standard.  They want to make sure you understand the risks and give you the appropriate trading level — I get that.  Selling covered calls is at the lowest level because the calls are covered by the stock you own, hence the term, “covered”  meaning if the stock does hit that price and you ARE forced to sell, you already own the stock so no real risk.

So anyway, I “applied” for option trading using a form which asked about my experience with and understanding of options — which, let’s be honest — even at a beginner level is way beyond what the average person trading options knows.  Most people just wing it by buying calls and puts and don’t ever bother learning about implied volatility, option greeks, or option strategies such as butterflies and iron condors.   Today, I got a letter from Fidelity telling me that I’ve been denied for option trading privileges.  No explanation or details on why or what I need to do to get approved. Seriously?

If I really cared, I’d call them up and try and get it worked out. But, the truth is I only wanted it to sell covered calls on my ESPP stock. I do all my real option trading at Think or Swim.

I’m filing this under “Lessons Learned” because it’s proof that the bigger brokers are completely inept when it comes to options trading and should not be used.  For options trading you need a broker that understands options and has policies and staff in place as well as a superior platform and execution time. Any broker who matches this description would never pull crap like this.  Think or Swim is my first choice but if for whatever reason you’re looking for alternatives, there’s also Tradeking and  OptionsXpress

I’m stepping off my soapbox now…

Comments (2)

  1. This sounds awfully familiar, except my experience was with Bank of America: http://vixandmore.blogspot.com/2007/12/good-luck-getting-mortgage-here.html

    It makes you wonder what sort of formulas these guys are using. Maybe we should stop blogging about options and spend more time trading them with TOS — a whose platform and features I grow more fond of each week.

    Be sure to send Fidelity a complimentary copy of your options trading book when it finally hits the presses. Ultimately, trading options well is the best revenge.

    Cheers,

    -Bill

  2. I have used TradeKing, OptionsXpress and Interactive brokers. I like Interactive brokers the most, they are also very cheap. Trade king is a great site.

Post a comment